If you're in Greencastle, Indiana, and on the hunt for a place where comfort meets deliciousness, look no further than Fairway Family Restaurant. Nestled at 1058 Indianapolis Rd, this charming eatery is designed with families in mind. With a welcoming atmosphere and attentive staff, it's no wonder diners are flocking to this local gem.
At Fairway Family Restaurant, the menu is a delightful blend of hearty options that cater to every palate. The Skillet Menu stands out with tempting offerings like the Western Skillet and Meat Lovers Skillet, both priced around $10.99. Each skillet is a flavor-packed dish, perfect for kicking off your day. The Veggie Skillet at $9.99 also ensures that vegetarian diners have their fill of satisfying choices.
For the seniors in our lives, Fairway offers a Senior Breakfast menu that includes classics like fluffy pancakes and French toast at just $5.99. This thoughtful touch showcases their commitment to catering to all generations. And let’s not overlook the Soup of the Day for a cozy, warm option at $5.99 – a perfect starter that complements the larger meals.
Reviews from happy customers paint a vibrant picture of the experience here. Ralph Bartley describes it as a “comfortable family-oriented restaurant,” emphasizing the staff's attentiveness and cleanliness. Linda Melton and Larriesha Goolsby similarly echo the sentiments of friendly service, making dining there a truly positive experience.
Whether it’s breakfast or lunch, the kitchen at Fairway doesn’t miss a beat, as noted by a repeat visitor who declared the food fantastic and the pricing fair. And let's give a nod to the enticing desserts like chocolate frogs – a fun and memorable treat that lingers in one's mind long after the meal is over.
As you approach Fairway Family Restaurant, the sight of a full parking lot, along with a quirky cow on the roof, beckons you to explore the tantalizing dishes within. Don’t let the initial photos deter you; this establishment proves that great food often resides in the most unexpected places. With the friendly staff and great food, it’s a place where you’ll want to linger, share stories, and create memorable dining moments with family and friends. All in all, Fairway is an experience worth savoring.
Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *
Ralph Bartley
12/09/2025
This is a very comfortable family oriented restaurant. The wait staff was very confident and attentive. The restaurant is clean and neat. They took extra care of the bathroom area asking to be notified if you found anything amiss. I will certainly dine there again and would recommend it to any friends.
Linda Melton
08/08/2025
Friendly staff and great food. This was are first time here would eat here again.
Larriesha Goolsby
04/08/2025
Great food and the staff was keeping up with the tables while the line was out the door. Keep up the great service.!
TM
30/07/2025
I made two visits in two days in March due to a family event in Greencastle....once for breakfast and once for lunch. The food was fantastic, the service was great, and I felt pricing was fair. I can't forget to give a shout out to the chocolate frogs!
Janet Sparks
20/07/2025
We almost didn't go here because the photos didn't look very appealing but we're glad we did. As we drove by we saw the full parking lot (and cow on roof) so we knew it had to be good. I added some yummy photos and hope it'll entice people to check out this great place!
Bee
19/07/2025
We were there on Friday around 6 pm. No wait. The staff was great. She thought the prime rib had hood flavor, but it was a little over cooked and dry. The chicken dumpling soup was good. My med rare ribeye sandwich was the best I've ever had. French fries were cooked perfectly. Coke and Pepsi products. It wasn't blasting music, and it was a super comfortable environment. I liked that the waitress checked on us even after she gave us the bill. I will try out their breakfast on the next visit
Leslie Booth
11/07/2025
This was my first time visiting and I will definitely be back. The service was amazing. Our waitress was super helpful and was always smiling. The food was very tasty and I had lots of leftovers for later. I've already been trekking others that they need to eat here.